LAMP

Lensless Actinic Metrology for EUV Photomasks

Started
September 1, 2022
Status
Completed
Share this project

Abstract

Extreme Ultraviolet (EUV) lithography is the current technology for semiconductor device manufacturing, and it will allow the industry to uphold Moore’s law in years to come. The use of the EUV wavelength (13.5 nm) allows a tremendous increase in the resolution but brings along several challenges that drive up the cost of the infrastructure for the metrology of various steps in the lithography process. At the XIL beamline of the SLS, PSI is pioneering the use of coherent diffraction imaging for the detection and the characterization of defects on EUV photomasks with the RESCAN microscope. RESCAN can detect defects as small as 50x50 nm² with an acquisition frame rate of 2 kHz. RESCAN is a demo tool, designed to inspect small samples with an area of 200x200 µm² , however the full photomask has an active area of about 100x100 mm² , which would require to collect at least 44M diffraction patterns to reconstruct the whole sample. Considering the required sampling and dynamic range required for this application, a complete diffraction data set will be of the order of 320 PB. The goal of the project was to develop efficient methods to reduce the data storage requirement, to optimize the image reconstruction procedure and avoid throughput throttling.

People

Collaborators

SDSC Team:
Suman Saha
Benjamín Béjar Haro

PI | Partners:

PSI, Advanced Lithography and Metrology Group:

  • Dr. Iacopo Mochi
  • Dr. Paolo Ansuinelli

More info

description

Motivation

Extreme Ultraviolet (EUV) lithography is the current technology for semiconductor device manufacturing, and it allows to uphold Moore’s law in upcoming years. The use of EUV wavelength (13.5 nm) allows a tremendous increase in the resolution, but at the same time, it also increases the cost of the infrastructure for the lithography process. PSI is pioneering a lensless imaging approach - ptychography or coherent diffraction imaging (CDI) - for EUV mask inspection. A dedicated imaging tool, RESCAN, has been built and developed in recent years. With RESCAN, the main challenge is that a very large computational infrastructure is needed to achieve the desired reconstruction speed, which is highly impractical. The objective of the project was to explore alternative data processing approaches to achieve the required reconstruction speed with an affordable hardware infrastructure. The development of a cost-effective framework for mask inspection would have an enormous impact on future technology development in semiconductor device manufacturing.

Proposed Approach / Solution

The proposed work introduced Ptycho-LDM, a novel deep learning-based framework for efficient and accurate phase retrieval of extreme ultraviolet (EUV) photomasks from diffraction patterns. It combined a physics-informed ptychographic algorithm (Fig. 1a) with a conditional Latent Diffusion Model (LDM) (Fig. 1b), a more computationally efficient variant of Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models (DDPMs). Unlike traditional approaches, Ptycho-LDM does not require additional posterior sampling steps, enabling faster inference.

To overcome the inefficiencies of standard ptychographic algorithms like Difference Map (DifMap)—which require many iterations and probe positions—Ptycho-LDM uses a hybrid strategy. First, a coarse spatial reconstruction is obtained with a reduced-iteration ptychographic method. Then, this is refined using the generative power of LDMs in a low-dimensional latent space, significantly reducing computational cost and reconstruction time.

Experiments show that Ptycho-LDM achieves a 10x speedup, reducing phase retrieval time from 174 seconds to just 0.5 seconds, while maintaining high fidelity. This approach leverages both the physical understanding of diffraction and the learning capabilities of deep generative models, setting a new benchmark in EUV mask imaging. It highlights the potential of integrating likelihood-based generative models with classical reconstruction techniques for real-world scientific applications.

A visual comparison of ptychographic phase retrieval is shown in Fig. 2 and  visual results of EUV Photomask Inspection is shown in Fig. 3.

Figure 1: Existing ptychographic algorithms, such as Difference Map (DifMap),require significantly longer reconstruction times due to two primary computationalbottlenecks: the number of iterations (K) needed for Fourier and complex objectupdates, and the number of probe positions (J) required to acquire a sufficient numberof diffraction patterns for high-quality phase retrieval. In contrast, our proposed Ptycho-LDM achieves significantly faster reconstruction by leveraging the state-of-the-artgenerative capabilities and faster sampling of conditional Latent Diffusion Models(LDMs), seamlessly integrated with a physics-based ptychographic iterative approach.Most importantly, the proposed Ptycho-LDM framework requires significantly feweriterations and probe positions, enabling much faster phase retrieval.
Figure 2: Visual comparison of ptychographic phase retrieval results for DifMap baselineand the proposed Ptycho-LDM on two photomasks. The top row depicts the entirephotomasks, while the bottom row presents zoomed-in center crops of the photomasks.Results are obtained under the "without prior" experimental setup, where DifMap’scomplex object is initialized with a random phase. Reconstructions use 200 DifMapiterations and 5 probe positions. DifMap reconstructions exhibit noise, which is usedas conditioning input for the Ptycho-LDM. The zoomed-in crops demonstrate thatPtycho-LDM effectively retrieves phase details closer to the ground truth photomasks.Due to the limited number of probe positions, the conditioning near the boundaries ofthe photomasks is suboptimal, leading to artifacts in the Ptycho-LDM reconstructionsthat are absent in the ground truth photomasks.
Figure 3: EUV Photomask Inspection. Phase reconstructions of four EUV photomasksamples using DifMap and the proposed Ptycho-LDM, compared against the groundtruth EUV photomask phase. Yellow arrows highlight correctly reconstructed defects,while red arrows indicate incorrect reconstructions. The results demonstrate that Ptycho-LDM achieves superior alignment with the ground truth, effectively reconstructing"extrusion" defects that are not perceptible in the DifMap outputs.

Impact

The impact of this work is significant in advancing semiconductor manufacturing technologies. Firstly, by implementing deep generative models for phase retrieval in ptychography, this approach has the potential to enhance the accuracy and resolution of defect detection on EUV photomasks. This improvement directly supports the industry's ability to enable the production of smaller, more powerful semiconductor devices. Secondly, the use of such advanced models reduces the computational load and associated costs compared to traditional methods, making the process more economically viable and potentially lowering the barrier to adoption for manufacturers. Finally, the application of machine learning and computer vision techniques, such as deep generative modeling and image-to-image translation, provides a novel pathway to overcome the challenges of high data volumes and dynamic range in lithography, thus improving the efficiency and speed of the imaging process.

Gallery

Annexe

Additional resources

Bibliography

  1. Bunday, B. D., Bello, A., Solecky, E. & Vaid, A. 7/5nm logic manufacturing capabilities and requirements of metrology in Metrology, Inspection, and Process Control for Microlithography XXXII (eds Adan, O. & Ukraintsev, V. A.) 10585 (SPIE, Mar. 2018), 17. isbn: 9781510616622. https://www.spiedigitallibrary.org/conference-  proceedings- of- spie/10585/2296679/75nm- logic-
    manufacturing-capabilities-and-requirements-of-metrology/10.1117/12.2296679.full.
  2. Miyai, H., Kohyama, T., Suzuki, T., Takehisa, K. & Kusunose, H. Actinic patterned mask defect inspection for EUV lithography in Photomask Technology 2019 (eds Rankin, J. H. & Preil, M. E.) 11148 (SPIE, 2019), 162–170. https://doi.org/10.1117/12.2538001.
  3. Thibault, P., Dierolf, M., Bunk, O., Menzel, A. & Pfeiffer, F. Probe retrieval in ptychographic coherent diffractive imaging. Ultramicroscopy 109, 338–343 (2009).
  4. Gardner, D. F. et al. High numerical aperture reflection mode coherent diffraction microscopy using off-axis apertured illumination. Optics Express 20. issn: 1094-4087 (2012).
  5. Harada, T., Nakasuji, M., Nagata, Y., Watanabe, T. & Kinoshita, H. Phase imaging of EUV masks using a lensless EUV microscope in (ed Kato, K.) 8701 (International Society for Optics and
    Photonics, June 2013), 870119. http : / / proceedings. spiedigitallibrary . org / proceeding . aspx?doi=10.1117/12.2027283.
  6. RESCAN: an actinic lensless microscope for defect inspection of EUV reticles
    I. Mochi, P. Helfenstein, I. Mohacsi, R. Rajeev, D. Kazazis, S. Yoshitake, and Y. Ekinci
    J. Micro/Nanolith. MEMS MOEMS 16(4), 041003 (2017)
    doi: 10.1117/1.JMM.16.4.041003
  7. Scanning coherent diffractive imaging methods for actinic EUV mask metrology
    P. Helfenstein, I. Mohacsi, R. Rajendran, and Y. Ekinci
    J. Micro/Nanolith. MEMS MOEMS 15(3), 034006 (2016)
    doi: 10.1117/1.JMM.15.3.034006

Publications

Related Pages

More projects

MAGNIFY

In Progress
Machine learning Assisted larGe scale quaNtIfication of building energy FlexibilitY
Energy, Climate & Environment

SPI-GreenFjord

In Progress
Energy, Climate & Environment

SPI-PAMIR

In Progress
Energy, Climate & Environment

TREMA

Completed
Transforming real estate management with AI
Engineering

News

Latest news

First National Calls: 50 selected projects to start in 2025
March 12, 2025

First National Calls: 50 selected projects to start in 2025

First National Calls: 50 selected projects to start in 2025

50 proposals were selected through the review processes of the SDSC's first National Calls.
AIXD | Generative AI toolbox for architects and engineers
January 22, 2025

AIXD | Generative AI toolbox for architects and engineers

AIXD | Generative AI toolbox for architects and engineers

Introducing AIXD (AI-eXtended Design), a toolbox for forward and inverse modeling for exhaustive design exploration.
Smartair | An active learning algorithm for real-time acquisition and regression of flow field data
May 1, 2024

Smartair | An active learning algorithm for real-time acquisition and regression of flow field data

Smartair | An active learning algorithm for real-time acquisition and regression of flow field data

We’ve developed a smart solution for wind tunnel testing that learns as it works, providing accurate results faster. It provides an accurate mean flow field and turbulence field reconstruction while shortening the sampling time.

Contact us

Let’s talk Data Science

Do you need our services or expertise?
Contact us for your next Data Science project!